Scribal Error

Scribal Error

Share this post

Scribal Error
Scribal Error
The Courageous Reish Lakish (article preview)

The Courageous Reish Lakish (article preview)

Gittin 47a

Joshua Waxman's avatar
Joshua Waxman
Jul 05, 2023
∙ Paid

Share this post

Scribal Error
Scribal Error
The Courageous Reish Lakish (article preview)
Share

Gittin 47a recounts Reish Lakish’s feat of strength and bravery. He sold himself to the Ludae, taking a sack containing a round stone with him. He said, “you have a tradition that on the person’s last day, they do anything he requests, so that they will forgive him for spilling his blood.” On the last day, they said to him, “what do you want?” He said to them, “I request that I tie you up in a sitting position, and each of you I will strike one and a half times.” Presumably unaware of the rock in the bag, they complied. He smote each of them such that “his soul left them”. He grimaced. He said, “are you laughing at me? I still owe you half a strike”. In this way, he killed them all.

There is much that is ambiguous in this story. Who are the Ludae? It could be people of a specific geographical area. Rashi and Aruch explain that Ludae were cannibals. The more recent explanation and accepted explanation is gladiators, as we trace לודאי to לודר, to λουδάριος which would refer to a gladiator or someone else connected to gladiatorial combat / the circus. This Greek transliteration would be of the Latin word, which derives from gladio = I use the sword + tor1. 

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Scribal Error to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Joshua Waxman
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share